Double Eagle Insurance

Your Trusted Partner for Personalized Insurance Solutions

At Double Eagle Insurance, we’re committed to helping you protect what matters most. As a local, independent agency with strong roots in the Evansville and Newburgh communities, we provide personalized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses alike. With over 10 years of experience, we understand the unique challenges you face and are here to guide you every step of the way. Whether it's safeguarding your home, business, or planning for the future with Medicare, our team is dedicated to providing the expertise and care you deserve.
A black and white speech bubble with three dots on a white background.

Discover how we can help you stay protected.

Executive Team

A man with a beard wearing a black shirt with his arms crossed

Jeff Fisher

Agency Manager

About Jeff
A man in a suit and tie is smiling for the camera.

Ahren Baumgart

Agency Principal

About Ahren
A woman in a black sweater is smiling with her arms crossed

Personal Lines Team

A woman in a black jacket is standing with her arms crossed and smiling.

Ann Nguyen

Personal Lines Account Manager

About Ann
A woman in a gray cardigan is standing with her hands on her hips.

Kristina Kuebler

Personal Lines Account Manager

About Kristina
A man with a beard is wearing a black shirt and smiling.

Nick Helmbrecht

Personal Lines Account Manager

About Nick
A bald man with a beard is wearing a black polo shirt with his arms crossed.

Noah Place

Personal Lines Account Manager

About Noah

Commercial Lines Team

A woman wearing glasses and a black shirt is smiling with her arms crossed.

Stacy Hein

Commercial Lines Account Manager

About Stacy
A woman wearing a black sweater and a necklace is smiling for the camera.

Our Mission

At Double Eagle Insurance, our mission is simple: to get to know you, understand your needs, and create customized insurance solutions that help you protect what’s most important. We aim to build long-lasting relationships with our clients by offering trusted advice, innovative thinking, and personalized service that keeps you covered through life’s uncertainties.
A black trophy with a star on it on a white background.
Putting You First
At Double Eagle Insurance, you are always our priority. We believe in taking the time to listen and understand your unique situation so we can recommend the right coverage to meet your needs. We work for you, not the insurance companies, which means we always have your best interests at heart.
A pair of hands holding a heart on a white background.
Innovative Solutions
In a world that’s constantly changing, we believe in thinking outside the box to protect what matters to you. Whether you're planning for tomorrow or protecting your assets today, we provide creative, forward-thinking insurance strategies designed to adapt to life’s unpredictable moments.
Ready to take the next step in protecting your future?

Let’s work together to create the right insurance plan for you.